Summary
The best answer is the one they find.
Most youth coaches tell players what to do: turn, pass, shoot, spread out. It feels effective, because the player does it straight away. But research shows that players learn more when the coach guides them to find the answer themselves, using well-designed practices and good questions.
We looked into the research on this approach, known as guided discovery. Below we summarise what the studies show, illustrate the difference with one moment from a training session, and give five steps to start using it yourself.
The problem
Why it matters
Football is a game of decisions. In every action a player has to see what is happening, choose an option and carry it out. When you tell a player what to do, you do the seeing and choosing for them. They execute, but the most important part of the game doesn’t get trained.
Most of us do this without noticing. In a study of 70 training sessions led by 25 youth coaches, most of the time went to instruction and feedback [1]. In another study, academy coaches said they wanted to develop “decision makers”, yet on the pitch they mainly gave prescriptive instructions [2]. And when coaches did ask questions, they were often leading questions with the answer already in them [3].
“Ultimately, it’s not about players developing the way I have in mind, but about me creating the conditions in which they can become the best version of themselves.”
The evidence
What the research says
Guided discovery works best. A review of 164 studies, mostly from classrooms but including movement skills, compared different ways of teaching [4]. Learners left to figure things out entirely on their own learned less than learners who were simply told. But learners who were guided to the answer, with feedback, support and being asked to explain their own thinking, learned the most.
It improves decisions and performance. In a small study, U16 volleyball players who reviewed their choices on video and had to explain the reasons behind them made better attacking decisions after eleven weeks [5]. Youth swimmers whose coach replaced much of his feedback with questions for a full season improved their technique and swam faster [6].
It boosts motivation. Coaches who give players choice, explain why things matter and leave room for initiative support players’ motivation from within [7]. At an elite youth football academy, players who felt this kind of support from their coach reported greater well-being over two seasons [8].
An honest note: much of this research comes from outside football, and some studies are small. But they point the same way.
In practice
One moment, two ways
Player A, a centre back in a U13 team, receives the ball from his goalkeeper during a training session. A striker sprints towards him. Player A tries to dribble past him, loses the ball, and two passes later the opponent scores. Player A’s head drops.
Telling
± 15 secondsThe coach calls out from the sideline:
Player A nods. For the rest of the session he passes the ball away as soon as he gets it, even when he has space to carry it forward.
What Player A learns
Don’t dribble, and mistakes get noticed.Asking
± 40 secondsThe coach lets the game run. When the ball goes out of play, he walks over to Player A and asks:
What Player A learns
When to pass and when to carry, in his own words.Player A hasn’t just learned that dribbling is risky. He found out himself what went wrong (he looked too late) and came up with his own rule for when to pass and when to carry the ball. And the mistake became something to learn from, not something to be ashamed of. On Saturday, when the coach can’t step in, that rule goes with him onto the pitch.
The FCI method
How to apply it
Guided discovery is not “let them figure it out” [4]. You choose the problem, you design the practice that brings it out, and you steer with questions. The player finds the answer, but you built the path to it. Here is how.
- 01
Turn your goal into a game problem.
Not an instruction, but a question the players have to solve themselves. Keep it to one problem per session, so every question you ask points the same way.
- 02
Design a practice where the problem keeps coming back.
Use the rules, the size of the pitch and the numbers to make the problem show up again and again. Reward more than one solution, or your rules give the answer for you. Across 28 studies with school pupils and athletes, game-based practice like this improved decision-making in game situations [9].
- 03
Let them play and coach with questions.
With young players, don’t stop the game: playing time is learning time. Ask your questions while play goes on, when the ball is out, or in a water break, one player or a small group at a time. With older players, a short freeze can help: stop straight after the moment, not in the middle of an action, and send players back to where they stood a few seconds before. Keep it under a minute.
- 04
Ask, and only narrow down when they are stuck.
Start wide and wait five seconds: in classrooms, teachers typically wait less than one second [10]. If no answer comes, make the question smaller. If they are still stuck, show it, then ask them to explain it back [4]. Accept every answer: even a “wrong” one tells you what the player doesn’t see yet.
Example: the moment right after losing the ball
Open“How were we positioned right after we lost the ball?”Focused“Who was closest to the ball when we lost it?”Choice“What would you do differently next time: press the ball as well, or screen the passing lines behind the player who presses?” - 05
Let them make their own rule, then test it.
Ask: “So what will you do next time?” Let them try their rule straight away. At the next moment, ask: “Did it work?” Praise the decision, not the outcome. Once they solve the problem, make it a little harder so they have to find the next answer.
Questions that make players think
- “What did you see?”
- “What were your options?”
- “What else could you have done?”
- “Why did you choose that?”
Questions that already hold the answer [3]
- “Shouldn’t you have pressed the ball?”
- “Did you check your shoulder?”
- “Was that the right choice?”
When to explain
Explain when it is a new technique or when safety is at stake. For decisions in the game, ask.
From the field
A coach’s view
Everything in this article starts with how you see your role as a coach. Quinten Dübendorfer, ex-Feyenoord Academy coach, explains his:
“My job is to guide players in their development, not in mine.”
I see myself mainly as a supporter and facilitator: someone who understands what a player needs and provides the right environment, space and guidance to grow.
I help players discover their qualities and areas for development, strengthen what they’re good at, encourage them to take new steps and challenge them to apply what they’ve learned in difficult situations too. That way, players become more independent and learn to take responsibility for their own development.
For me, development goes beyond football. By connecting with each player’s personal development needs and giving them room to make their own choices and take responsibility, they develop skills and insights that benefit them not only on the pitch, but for the rest of their lives.

That is exactly what asking instead of telling makes possible. Questions put the player at the centre, give them room to choose and help them take ownership of their own development [7].
The real test
Not what players do when you tell them, but what they do when you can’t.
Every question you ask in training is practice for the moments when you can’t help.
Sources
- Ford, P. R., Yates, I., & Williams, A. M. (2010). An analysis of practice activities and instructional behaviours used by youth soccer coaches during practice. Journal of Sports Sciences, 28(5), 483–495. Link
- Partington, M., & Cushion, C. (2013). An investigation of the practice activities and coaching behaviours of professional top-level youth soccer coaches. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 23(3), 374–382. Link
- Cope, E., Partington, M., Cushion, C. J., & Harvey, S. (2016). An investigation of professional top-level youth football coaches’ questioning practice. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 8(4), 380–393. Link
- Alfieri, L., Brooks, P. J., Aldrich, N. J., & Tenenbaum, H. R. (2011). Does discovery-based instruction enhance learning? Journal of Educational Psychology, 103(1), 1–18. Link
- Gil-Arias, A., Moreno, M. P., García-Mas, A., Moreno, A., García-González, L., & Del Villar, F. (2016). Reasoning and action: implementation of a decision-making program in sport. The Spanish Journal of Psychology, 19, e60. Link
- Chambers, K. L., & Vickers, J. N. (2006). Effects of bandwidth feedback and questioning on the performance of competitive swimmers. The Sport Psychologist, 20, 184–197. Link
- Mageau, G. A., & Vallerand, R. J. (2003). The coach–athlete relationship: a motivational model. Journal of Sports Sciences, 21(11), 883–904. Link
- Adie, J. W., Duda, J. L., & Ntoumanis, N. (2012). Perceived coach-autonomy support, basic need satisfaction and the well- and ill-being of elite youth soccer players: A longitudinal investigation. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 13(1), 51–59. Link
- Manninen, M., Magrum, E., Campbell, S., & Belton, S. (2025). The effect of game-based approaches on decision-making, knowledge, and motor skill: A systematic review and a multilevel meta-analysis. European Physical Education Review, 31(1), 18–32. Link
- Rowe, M. B. (1986). Wait time: slowing down may be a way of speeding up! Journal of Teacher Education, 37(1), 43–50. Link


